Skip to content

EBU R128 vs ATSC A/85: Broadcast Loudness Standards

Send feedback

Last updated 7 min readTags:MasteringLoudnessBroadcast

Compare EBU R128 and ATSC A/85 loudness targets, true-peak limits and measurement methods, with a practical broadcast export workflow.

EBU R128 and ATSC A/85 set loudness recommendations for broadcast audio. EBU R128 uses a target of −23 LUFS; ATSC A/85 normally uses −24 LKFS. LUFS and LKFS are equivalent units, so the targets are 1 dB apart.

For a finished music master, a broadcast version may need only a gain adjustment. You must also check true peak and any limits on the loudest sections. First, establish what you are delivering: a music track for someone else to mix, or the finished advert or programme.

EBU R128 vs ATSC A/85

Requirement EBU R128 ATSC A/85
Broadcast loudness target −23 LUFS −24 LKFS by default, without loudness metadata or a different prior agreement
True-peak limit No higher than −1 dBTP for linear audio; some delivery chains require lower peaks Keep below −2 dBTP
What to measure Generally the whole programme mix Whole mix for short-form content; dialogue loudness for long-form programmes with dialogue
Additional short-form limit Maximum short-term loudness of −18 LUFS under R128 s1 No equivalent maximum short-term limit in A/85 itself

These values describe the recommendations. Confirm the recipient's specification, including the required version of the standard, measurement method and file format.

Both standards address the same problem: programmes with similar peak levels can sound very different in loudness. Their measurements distinguish between average perceived level and the highest peaks.

  • Integrated loudness measures loudness across the item. The measurement method determines which parts contribute to the result.
  • True peak estimates the highest level of the reconstructed waveform, including peaks between samples. It is measured in dBTP.
  • Maximum short-term loudness is the highest reading from a sliding three-second loudness measurement.

The LUFS and true peak reference pages explain those measurements in more detail.

Are you delivering a music track or the finished programme?

A track licensed for an advert becomes one element of a mix that may also contain speech and sound effects. Its loudness alone cannot establish whether the finished advert meets the delivery specification.

If you are supplying music to a production company, follow its instructions for the music file. Ask whether it wants your usual master, an alternative with less limiting, stems, or a file at a specified level. Do not assume the programme loudness target applies separately to your track.

If you are supplying the finished advert or programme, measure the complete item that will be delivered. That includes its final edits, fades, speech and effects. A compliant full-length song does not guarantee that an excerpt, or an advert built from it, will pass.

Why the measurement method matters

Under EBU R128, programme loudness generally comes from the whole mix, measured with a compliant BS.1770 and EBU-mode meter. The measurement uses level gating, which excludes material below specified thresholds.

Under ATSC A/85, adverts and other short-form items also use a whole-mix integrated measurement. Long-form programmes with dialogue normally use dialogue-gated loudness: the measurement selects passages containing speech from the complete mix. It does not mean measuring an isolated dialogue stem.

A normal full-mix integrated reading cannot substitute for that dialogue-based result. If you are delivering a long-form TV programme, use the measurement method the recipient requires. For programmes with no dialogue, A/85 provides separate guidance on matching their perceived loudness to dialogue-based content.

How to prepare a broadcast version

For a music-only file with an agreed whole-mix target, or a finished short-form item, start with a gain adjustment. Leave the existing dynamics processing alone unless the adjusted file exceeds another limit.

1. Measure the complete file

Reset your loudness meter and measure from start to finish. Record integrated loudness and maximum true peak. For an R128 s1 delivery, record maximum short-term loudness as well.

Use the actual delivery edit. A measurement of the chorus or the loudest passage will not give you the file's integrated loudness.

2. Calculate the gain adjustment

Subtract the measured integrated loudness from the target:

Gain adjustment = target loudness − measured loudness

For a master at −9 LUFS and an R128 target of −23 LUFS:

−23 − (−9) = −14 dB

Reduce the file's gain by 14 dB. For an A/85 target of −24 LKFS, the reduction would be 15 dB.

3. Apply gain after any dynamics processing

The simplest method is to import the finished file into a clean session and use a gain plugin or clip gain. If you work in the original session, put the adjustment after any compressor, limiter or other processor whose response depends on input level.

Changing a limiter's threshold changes its processing. A separate output gain control may simply change level, but its behaviour depends on the plugin. A dedicated gain plugin after the existing processing is easier to check.

4. Export and measure again

Use the recipient's required sample rate, bit depth, channel layout and file format. Do not apply peak normalisation during export.

Measure the exported file again with the required meter settings. Confirm its integrated loudness, true peak and any additional limits against the delivery sheet.

Worked example: a master at −9 LUFS

Suppose the exact music file you have been asked to deliver measures:

  • Integrated loudness: −9 LUFS
  • Maximum true peak: −0.8 dBTP
  • Maximum short-term loudness: −7 LUFS

The expected results after a straightforward gain adjustment are:

Measurement Original R128 version: −14 dB gain A/85 version: −15 dB gain
Integrated loudness −9 LUFS −23 LUFS −24 LKFS
Maximum true peak −0.8 dBTP −14.8 dBTP −15.8 dBTP
Maximum short-term loudness −7 LUFS −21 LUFS −22 LUFS

The R128 version is below both the −1 dBTP peak limit and the s1 short-term limit of −18 LUFS. The A/85 version is below its −2 dBTP peak recommendation. Re-measure each export to confirm the results.

A peak limit is a ceiling, not a level you need to reach. The low true peaks in this example are acceptable. Raising them would also raise loudness unless you changed the dynamics.

When a gain adjustment is not enough

The adjusted file exceeds the true-peak limit

A dynamic recording might measure −24 LUFS with a maximum true peak of −1 dBTP. Raising it by 1 dB reaches −23 LUFS, but its peak then reaches 0 dBTP, above R128's −1 dBTP limit.

In that case, control the transients responsible with a true-peak limiter, automation or suitable compression. Then measure again and recalculate the gain adjustment. You need to meet the loudness target and peak limit together.

An R128 advert exceeds the short-term limit

R128 s1 adds a maximum short-term loudness of −18 LUFS. At the −23 LUFS integrated target, the loudest three-second measurement can therefore be no more than 5 LU above the integrated reading.

For example, an advert might measure −23 LUFS integrated but reach −17.5 LUFS short-term during its final section. Its average meets the target; that section exceeds the short-term limit by 0.5 LU.

Lower the loud section relative to the rest with automation or compression, then measure the whole advert again. The edit also changes integrated loudness, so check both readings after the final gain adjustment. A true-peak limiter may leave this problem untouched if the section is consistently loud without large peaks.

Should you master every music release to −23 LUFS?

There is no general requirement to deliver music releases at the EBU broadcast target. Prepare your release for its intended use and make a separate broadcast version when a recipient requests one.

Turning down a heavily limited master preserves its existing sound and dynamics. It does not restore peaks that were removed during mastering. If the production needs a more dynamic version, return to the session or a suitable earlier export and revise the processing.

Sonalix's mix analysis provides feedback on your music. For a broadcast delivery, check the finished export against the recipient's specification with the required metering method.

Sources

Was this page helpful?

    Type to search titles, headings and summaries.