Skip to content

Haas effect: stereo width, delay settings and mono checks

Send feedback

Last updated 6 min readTags:MixingStereoProduction Techniques

Learn how the Haas effect changes stereo placement, how to set up a short delay, and how to reduce the comb filtering it can cause in mono.

The Haas effect describes how a sound and a closely delayed version can be heard as one event, with its apparent position dominated by whichever arrives first. It is commonly discussed as part of the broader precedence effect.1

In a mix, you can use this behaviour to change a mono sound's apparent position and width. Pan the original left and a slightly delayed copy right, and the sound will usually seem to come mainly from the left, with added spaciousness. The drawback appears when the channels are summed to mono: the two versions interfere, which can make the sound hollow or thin.2

What a short delay changes

A pan control changes the relative level of a sound in the left and right channels. A Haas delay introduces a timing difference. Even if both versions have the same level, the earlier one can dominate the perceived position.

That distinction matters when you want width. Equal levels on the left and right do not guarantee a centred image once one side is delayed. If the part seems pulled towards the earlier side, that is an expected result of the technique.

There is no single delay time at which all sounds turn into echoes. The threshold depends on the source, the delayed level and the listener. Short clicks can become separate events at much shorter delays than sustained material. Hearing a separate repeat and judging its direction are also distinct aspects of the precedence effect.1

For mixing, start around 10–20 milliseconds and adjust by ear. This is a practical starting point, rather than a fixed perceptual boundary. A sharp percussion hit may already sound doubled at a setting that works well on a sustained guitar or synth.

How to set up a Haas delay

Try this on a supporting guitar, backing vocal or synth part:

  1. Pan the mono source to one side. Start hard left so the routing is easy to hear.
  2. Send it to an auxiliary channel and pan that hard right. Insert a simple delay on the auxiliary.
  3. Set the delay to 100% wet, with feedback at zero. The auxiliary should contain one delayed copy, without another dry signal or further repeats.
  4. Start with a 10 ms delay and the copy about 6 dB below the original. If the send is at unity, use the auxiliary fader for this level difference.
  5. Adjust the delay, level and pan positions in the mix. Listen for a useful increase in space, an unwanted pull to one side, or a distinct second attack.
  6. Switch to mono and bypass the auxiliary for comparison. Listen for changes in tone and prominence. Reduce any overall loudness difference before deciding whether the effect is better.

The quieter copy makes a sensible first trial because it reduces the severity of mono comb filtering. You can raise it if the part needs more width, but check the result again.3

Why Haas widening can sound hollow in mono

When the channels are summed, the original and delayed copy combine. Some frequencies reinforce each other; others partially or completely cancel. The repeated peaks and dips in the frequency response are called comb filtering.4

For identical, equal-level copies with unchanged polarity, the first cancellation frequency is:

First notch in Hz = 1000 ÷ (2 × delay in milliseconds)

The other notches follow at regular intervals:

Delay First notch Next two notches
5 ms 100 Hz 300 Hz, 500 Hz
10 ms 50 Hz 150 Hz, 250 Hz
20 ms 25 Hz 75 Hz, 125 Hz

These values are calculated from the delay. The pattern continues through the midrange and treble; it does not stop after the frequencies shown in the table.

At equal levels, an ideal pair can cancel completely at the notch frequencies. A quieter copy makes the dips shallower. A longer delay moves the notches closer together, so increasing the delay does not remove comb filtering.4

The same interference occurs whether you intended the delay to change placement or width. Use the mono check for either purpose.

How to reduce the tonal change

Lower the delayed copy first. This reduces its contribution to both reinforcement and cancellation. Stop when the stereo effect still serves the part and its mono tone remains acceptable.

Filter the copy where necessary. A high-pass filter reduces the delayed bass content, so it reduces low-frequency interference. A low-pass filter can soften a distracting second attack. Neither removes comb filtering across the whole spectrum, and the filters themselves change the copy's phase response.3

Adjust the delay while listening in mono. Small changes move the notches relative to the source's harmonics. One setting may preserve a guitar's body better than another, even if the stereo width sounds similar.3

Judge the result in the full mix as well as in solo. A small tonal change may be acceptable on a background texture, but troublesome on a part whose clarity or weight is essential. The mono compatibility guide covers what to listen for.

When another technique is a better choice

If you only need to move a sound left or right, start with ordinary panning. It does not introduce a delayed duplicate.

If you can record another performance, double tracking gives you differences in timing, pitch and articulation. It avoids the fixed, repeating cancellation pattern of an exact delayed copy, though you should still check the two performances together in mono.

If another take is unavailable, automatic double tracking uses processed copies to imitate some of those differences. Its mono behaviour depends on the processing.

Some wideners add an effect only to the side component of a mid/side signal. With correct routing and an unchanged mid component, that added effect cancels in the mono sum. This is a specific arrangement, rather than a guarantee that all mid/side processing preserves mono compatibility.2

Keep a Haas delay when its stereo position and width suit the part, and its mono version retains the tone and level the mix needs.

Sources

  1. Litovsky and Shinn-Cunningham, Investigation of the relationship among three common measures of precedence, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2001. Distinguishes perceptual fusion from localisation dominance.
  2. Ian Stewart, What Is the Haas Effect and How to Use It, iZotope, 2022. Covers delay routing, mono interference and a side-only alternative.
  3. Ian Stewart, 6 Tips for Widening the Stereo Image of a Mix, iZotope, 2022. Covers delayed-signal attenuation, filtering and adjustment in mono. The starting settings above are practical suggestions, not universal targets.
  4. Julius O. Smith III, Feedforward Comb Filters and Comb Filter Amplitude Response, Physical Audio Signal Processing. The table applies the equal-level response to the stated delay times.

Was this page helpful?

    Type to search titles, headings and summaries.