Why is my master loud but flat?
Last updated 2 min readTags:TroubleshootingMixing
Compare a master with its premaster at matched loudness and find where drum impact or section contrast has gone.
Turn your master down to the level of the premaster or a suitable reference. Compare the kick and snare attacks, then listen to the move from verse to chorus. This separates the impact of the processing from the immediate impression of extra level.
Find out where the contrast went
If the premaster has more punch, check the final limiter first. Back off its input, match the output level, and compare the loudest section. Then check any fast bus compressor and clipper in turn. An AES study in 2014 tested four compressors and four limiters. The limiters reduced crest factor, and fast-attack compressors reduced both crest factor and longer-term dynamics.
Crest factor compares peak level with RMS. PLR compares true peak with integrated loudness. A smaller value can point to a denser result. To hear whether a processor is responsible, compare the same passage with it bypassed at matched level. See limiting and over-compression.
If the premaster is already flat, work on the mix. Listen to the level and arrangement on either side of the chorus. If the drums barely come forwards, try reducing the surrounding parts or automating the drum level there. If the transient is already dull on the drum bus, the final limiter has little attack left to preserve. See preparing a mix for mastering.
Judge the master at the level listeners will hear it
Spotify Normal uses −14 LUFS for playback and turns louder masters down. Any transient reduction you hear at matched volume remains after that gain change. Spotify also notes a higher risk of encoding distortion on louder masters. YouTube's Stable volume is a separate playback feature, on by default for eligible videos and off for YouTube Music and official music videos. See loudness normalisation and the loudness war.
A dense master may suit the track. Keep the version that works at matched level. If the whole mix surges with the kick, check master pumping. For delivery issues, see quieter playback on Spotify and distortion after upload.