Why does my bass disappear on small speakers?
Last updated 2 min readTags:TroubleshootingMixing
Keep bass notes audible on phones and laptops by checking harmonics, playback level and the mix around the bass.
If you can hear the kick on a phone but can barely follow the bass line, start with the bass patch. A clean, sine-like sub can carry most of its energy in a fundamental that the speaker barely reproduces. More sub level will mainly make it louder on systems that already reproduce it.
See if the notes survive
Play the bass alone on the small speaker, then in the mix. If you can follow the notes in solo, see what covers them in the arrangement. Start with kick and bass. If the notes are faint even in solo, look at the bass on a spectrum analyser. Check for energy an octave or two above the fundamental.
Harmonics are multiples of that fundamental. If the speaker reproduces enough of them, the ear may still infer the original pitch. This is the missing fundamental effect. You can make the bass line intelligible on a phone while keeping its sub weight for larger speakers.
Give a sine bass some harmonics
Try gentle saturation or blend in a high-passed, distorted copy. An octave-up layer is another option if it suits the part. On a clean sub patch, audition the added energy around 200–800 Hz as a starting region. Stop once the notes are easy to follow in the full mix.
Check the result on your monitors at a comparable volume. If the bass has become gritty or crowds the vocal, bring the harmonic layer down. If the lows are wide and lose level when summed, test mono bass on the source before widening it again.
Rule out the room and playback level
At quiet playback, bass is harder to hear. Below about 100 Hz, equal-loudness contours can rise by as much as 24 dB per octave towards lower frequencies. Check at your usual monitoring level and at a lower setting. A room mode can also exaggerate bass at your seat. Play a reference track on both systems before changing the mix.
If the bass sounds weak on full-range speakers too, see why a mix sounds thin. For bass that swells on a few notes, see boomy low end.