Why is my song quieter on Spotify than other tracks?
Last updated 2 min readTags:TroubleshootingMixing
Check Spotify’s playback setting, headroom and level before changing the density or tone of your master.
Compare both tracks on the same device, in the same playback mode. If the difference persists in the Spotify app with normalisation on, check the delivered file's integrated loudness and true peak. Then compare the sections that sound different at matched level.
Check the playback setting
Spotify's playback levels are −11 LUFS for Loud, −14 LUFS for Normal and −19 LUFS for Quiet. Loud sits 3 LU above Normal and can apply a limiter. The web player and certain third-party devices do not use normalisation. Spotify applies one gain adjustment during album playback and can adjust tracks individually during shuffle or in playlists.
A quiet master may also run out of room before Spotify can bring it up to Normal. Spotify leaves 1 dB of headroom for lossy encoding when it applies positive gain. For example, a master at −20 LUFS with a −5 dBTP maximum can gain about 4 dB, reaching −16 LUFS. See LUFS and loudness normalisation.
Compare the chorus at matched level
Two tracks at the same integrated LUFS can have different verse-to-chorus contrast, loud sections or tonal balance. Loop the comparable sections. Check short-term loudness and listen to the vocal, bass and drum hits. Hearing is particularly sensitive around 2–5 kHz, so two different balances can feel different on a phone. See tonal balance.
If one snare hit is driving the limiter, try reducing that hit with clip gain and back off the limiter. If your kick already lost its attack, try less limiting first. PLR is true peak minus integrated loudness. Crest factor uses peak and RMS. Both add context, but neither proves a mix will sound louder.
Check delivery headroom
Spotify's guidance is to target around −14 LUFS integrated and keep true peaks below −1 dBTP, or below −2 dBTP if the master is louder than −14 LUFS. These are Spotify's mastering recommendations. Listen to an encoded preview if you are pushing the level. A hotter master can be more prone to encoding distortion.
Other services have their own playback behaviour. YouTube's Stable volume is on by default for eligible videos and off for YouTube Music and official music videos. See streaming loudness targets, loud but flat masters and distortion after upload.