How to use reference tracks when mixing
Last updated 4 min readTags:MixingReference TracksAnalysis
Choose a reference track, route it around your mix-bus processing, match it by loudness and use what you hear to make better mix decisions.
A reference track is a recording you play alongside your mix to judge things like vocal level, bass balance or how hard the drums hit. Compare similar sections at roughly the same loudness. A louder release can sound fuller or punchier simply because it’s louder.
1. Choose a track that answers a question
Start with one recording you know well and whose arrangement suits the comparison. If you’re checking vocal level, find a track with a similar lead and a similarly busy backing. If you’re checking the low end, look for a track where the kick and bass do much the same jobs as yours. Use a second reference if the first only helps with one of those questions.
Use a local WAV or FLAC if you have one. A good-quality stream can still tell you whether your vocal is too far back. A local file makes it easier to cue the same passage, adjust its level and switch quickly.
2. Route the reference around your mix bus
Import the reference to its own stereo track. Send it to the same monitoring output as your mix, but bypass the mix-bus EQ, compressor and limiter. Leave your mix-bus settings in place for your own mix. If you use room or headphone correction, keep it active for both signals.
If your DAW has a single master channel, one option is to route your mix tracks to a stereo bus and put your mix processing there. Send that bus and the reference track separately to the master output. A reference plug-in at the end of your mix chain can also do the job if it plays its reference files directly.
Set up the switch so you hear only one source at a time. Keep the speaker or headphone volume fixed.
3. Match loudness over comparable sections
Pick passages with a similar role and density, such as two full choruses. Use the same meter on both signals, after mix processing and reference trim but before monitor correction. Short-term LUFS measures loudness over the previous three seconds, so give the meter a few seconds to settle after each switch. See integrated, short-term and momentary loudness.
If your chorus is around −20 LUFS and the reference chorus is around −9 LUFS, turn the reference down by about 11 dB with its own gain or trim. Switch back and forth and adjust by ear if one still sounds louder. If your mix is the louder one, turn it down after the mix-bus processing. Check the match again when you switch sections. Even if the choruses match, the reference may have a quieter verse.
4. Listen for one thing at a time
Start with whatever you’re unsure about. Switch back and forth over a short passage and put what you hear into a sentence.
| If you’re checking… | Listen for… |
|---|---|
| Kick and bass | Can you follow the bass notes and still hear the kick clearly? |
| Mids and lead | Does the vocal stay intelligible when the guitars or keys come in? |
| Top end | Do cymbals or consonants draw more attention in your mix? |
| Width and mono | Which sounds sit out to the sides? Do any important parts get much quieter when you switch to mono? |
| Depth | How close does the lead sound? How audible are the delay repeats or reverb tails between phrases? |
| Dynamics | How clearly do drum hits stand out from the sounds around them? How much does the verse lift into the chorus? |
If you hear a tonal difference and want to locate it, look at the same passages on a spectrum analyser with the same settings. Arrangement and note choices affect the curve, so treat a broad difference as a reason to listen again. Likewise, mastering can alter the transients and dynamics of a finished reference. If its drums sound different, check your own drum and bus processing before reaching for a limiter.
5. Try one mix change, then compare again
Suppose the reference vocal stays clear through the chorus, while yours is clear in the verse and disappears when the guitars come in. Try pulling the guitars down 1 dB in the chorus. If that brings the vocal back but leaves the guitars too quiet, restore their level and listen for frequency masking. A small cut on the guitars where they compete with the vocal may work better.
If the drums sound softer in your mix, try bypassing the drum-bus compressor and match the bypassed level to the processed level. If the hits come back, try a slower attack or less gain reduction. See bus compression.
After an edit, check the loudness match again and listen to the same passage. Keep the edit if it solves the problem in your song. If you’re happy with how the part sits, leave the difference alone.